When it comes to working at height, scissor lifts offer a safe and efficient way to get the job done. However, one important decision to make is whether to use an electric or diesel-powered scissor lift. At Premier Platforms, we offer a full range of both, so we’ve put together this comparison to help you figure out which type best suits your project’s needs.
What is an Electric Scissor Lift?
Electric scissor lifts are powered by rechargeable batteries, offering emission-free and quiet operation. They are designed primarily for indoor use, though they can also be used outdoors in the right conditions.
Where are electric scissor lifts used?
Electric scissor lifts are best suited for indoor projects where ventilation and noise control are important. They’re commonly used in:
- Warehouses and factories
- Shopping centres
- Hospitals and schools
- Office buildings
These environments often have smooth floors and limited space, making the compact design and non-marking tyres of electric lifts perfect for the job.
Advantages of electric scissor lifts
- Quiet operation: Electric motors are almost silent compared to diesel engines, making them ideal for noise-sensitive environments.
- Emission-free: Since they run on batteries, they produce no exhaust fumes, maintaining good indoor air quality.
- Low maintenance: Fewer moving parts and simpler mechanics mean electric scissor lifts tend to require less upkeep compared to diesel models.
Disadvantages of electric scissor lifts
- Limited power: Electric models typically have less torque and are less effective on rough or uneven surfaces.
- Battery life: Depending on the job, the battery life can be a limitation. Running out of power mid-shift could cause delays unless you’re prepared with a fully charged backup.
What is a Diesel Scissor Lift?
Diesel scissor lifts are powered by internal combustion engines, providing more strength and the ability to handle rugged outdoor terrain. They are ideal for larger projects that demand power and endurance.
Where are diesel scissor lifts used?
Diesel scissor lifts excel in outdoor and heavy-duty environments, such as:
- Construction sites
- Outdoor maintenance jobs
- Large-scale building projects
They’re designed to handle uneven ground and their larger tyres allow them to move through dirt, mud or rough terrain.
Advantages of diesel scissor lifts
- Powerful performance: Diesel lifts offer more torque, which is essential for rough terrain or projects that require lifting heavy loads.
- Longer operation: Since they run on fuel, diesel lifts can operate longer without the need for charging.
- Higher load capacity: Diesel models generally have a higher load capacity, making them suitable for jobs involving heavy tools, equipment or multiple workers.
Disadvantages of diesel scissor lifts
- Noise: Diesel engines are loud, which can be disruptive in areas where noise control is a priority.
- Emissions: These lifts produce exhaust fumes, so they’re not suitable for indoor use or enclosed spaces.
- Maintenance: Diesel engines require regular maintenance and servicing to keep them in good condition, potentially increasing overall costs.
Comparing Electric vs Diesel Scissor Lifts
To make the right choice between electric and diesel scissor lifts, consider the key factors below:
1. Environment
- Indoor Projects: Electric scissor lifts are the clear winner due to their quiet, emission-free operation.
- Outdoor Projects: Diesel scissor lifts provide the power and durability needed for rugged outdoor environments.
2. Surface Conditions
- Smooth and Flat Surfaces: Electric lifts work best on smooth, flat floors like those found in warehouses and retail spaces.
- Rough and Uneven Terrain: Diesel lifts excel on construction sites or uneven outdoor surfaces where extra power and durable tyres are needed.
3. Noise and Emissions
- Quiet, Emission-Free Work: If noise or air quality is a concern, electric scissor lifts are the best option.
- Power Over Noise: If noise is less of a factor and power is more important, diesel scissor lifts provide the strength and capability for tougher jobs.
Other Access Platforms and Training at Premier Platforms
At Premier Platforms, we provide more than just scissor lifts. If your project requires even greater height or reach, consider our range of boom lifts or cherry pickers, ideal for accessing hard-to-reach areas. For smaller, low-level tasks, we also offer low-level 3a PAV platforms, which are great for tasks that don’t require extensive height but still demand safety and stability.
To ensure safety on the job, we also provide IPAF operator training courses. Whether you’re new to using access platforms or simply need a refresher, these courses will ensure that everyone on your team is fully trained and confident in operating the equipment.
How to Choose the Right Scissor Lift
Choosing between an electric and diesel scissor lift depends on the specific requirements of your project. If you’re working indoors or in an area where noise and emissions are a concern, electric lifts are your best option. For outdoor, rugged tasks that require more power and durability, diesel lifts will get the job done efficiently. However, even this general rule of thumb isn’t the be-all and end-all with numerous other factors to consider such as budget, worksite conditions and even how the equipment will be used by its driver.
Explore Our Full Range of Access Equipment
At Premier Platforms, we offer a full range of electric and diesel scissor lifts to suit all project types. Whether you need to tackle indoor tasks, navigate uneven outdoor terrain or handle high-capacity loads, we have the equipment that will meet your needs. Don’t forget to explore our additional access platforms like boom lifts and cherry pickers, as well as our IPAF training courses to ensure your team is fully prepared.
Get in touch with us today and we’ll help you choose the perfect access platform for your next project!